Justice, Work and Dignity

The Letter From Bitter Creek · Chapter 1 of 6

Chapter 1

By My Life Story Editorial · Published · Updated

The year was 1883, and the October wind came down through Bitter Creek, Wyoming, with enough force to rattle windows, lift dust from the road, and make every loose board in Abigail Higgins's boarding house complain.

Martha Higgins barely noticed.

She had been standing beside the cast-iron stove since before sunrise.

At twenty-four, Martha had learned that work could silence almost anything.

It silenced hunger.

It silenced loneliness.

Sometimes, if she worked until her arms trembled and her back ached, it even silenced the things people said about her.

Almost.

"Martha!"

Her stepmother's voice cut through the kitchen wall.

"Yes, ma'am."

"Mr. Bellamy wants more biscuits."

Martha glanced at the empty basket on the counter.

She had already baked forty-two.

"I'll make another batch."

"And don't take all morning. Men paying twenty cents for breakfast expect food before noon."

Martha lowered her eyes.

"Yes, ma'am."

The kitchen door slammed.

She heard laughter from the dining room.

Martha knew the sound well.

Some laughter was warm.

Some invited you closer.

This kind told you that you were safer staying behind the kitchen door.

She reached for the flour.

Martha was a large woman by the standards of Bitter Creek. Her hips were wide, her arms thick from years of lifting sacks, hauling water, kneading dough, and carrying cast-iron pots that Clementine Higgins claimed were too heavy for "a proper lady."

Her face was round and soft. Heat from the stove left her cheeks pink most of the day. Loose strands of brown hair escaped whatever pins she used before breakfast.

Her half-sister Clementine once said Martha always looked as though she had been running uphill.

Clementine had inherited Abigail's narrow waist, pale skin, and talent for appearing helpless whenever a man entered the room.

Martha had inherited none of those things.

She had inherited her father's hands.

Strong hands.

Working hands.

Hands capable of turning almost nothing into something people remembered.

That morning, she made biscuits from flour that had begun to smell faintly stale, rendered fat saved from supper, and the last spoonful of buttermilk.

When they came from the oven, they rose in golden layers.

Martha brushed their tops with butter.

She placed six in a basket.

Then she stopped.

Her stomach twisted.

She had eaten half an apple the previous evening and nothing that morning.

For a moment she considered taking the smallest biscuit.

Nobody would know.

Then she heard Abigail complaining that the pantry was running low again.

Martha put the biscuit back.

She carried the basket into the dining room.

Conversations softened.

Not completely.

Just enough.

Mr. Bellamy, a traveling salesman with a red mustache, leaned back in his chair.

"Careful there, boys," he said. "Floorboards are already old."

Three men laughed.

Martha placed the biscuits down.

"Fresh from the oven."

A younger man looked embarrassed.

He gave her a quiet nod.

"Thank you, Miss Higgins."

Those four words nearly hurt worse than the joke.

Kindness had become so rare that Martha no longer knew what to do with it.

She returned to the kitchen.

Clementine was waiting.

At nineteen, Clementine wore pale dresses even while living in a boarding house where coal dust drifted under doors.

She held a corset against her waist.

"Mother says I need this altered."

Martha looked at the pile of breakfast dishes.

"When?"

"Before Saturday."

"I have twenty rooms to help clean."

Clementine sighed.

"You always act as if everything is difficult."

Martha stared at her.

Clementine's expression remained perfectly sincere.

"I'll try."

"You could lose some weight if you wanted, you know."

Martha said nothing.

"I mean it kindly."

Of course she did.

"Maybe if you ate less of your own cooking."

Martha looked at the untouched biscuit basket through the doorway.

"I'll remember that."

Clementine smiled.

"There. See? I was only trying to help."

She floated away.

Martha waited until the door closed.

Then she pressed both hands against the table and breathed.

Her father had been dead for three years.

Three years since a support beam collapsed in the Red Hollow mine and buried him with six other men.

Three years since Abigail became the owner of the boarding house.

Three years since Martha's place within the family quietly changed.

While her father lived, she had been Martha.

Afterward, she became labor.

Cook.

Cleaner.

Washerwoman.

Errand runner.

The woman who carried trunks when guests arrived.

The woman who repaired curtains at midnight.

The woman blamed when accounts came short.

Abigail repeatedly claimed that Martha's appetite had ruined the family.

It was absurd.

Martha ate less than anyone in the house.

But lies became truth in Bitter Creek when repeated by someone respectable enough.

And Abigail Higgins looked respectable.

That afternoon, Martha was trimming spoiled pieces from potatoes when she heard a man's cane striking the parlor floor.

Tap.

Tap.

Tap.

She recognized it before she recognized the voice.

Horace Grimsby.

Every merchant in town knew him.

Every debtor feared him.

Grimsby owned warehouses, wagons, several questionable mining claims, and at least one work camp near the Dakota border.

Rumors said women who entered his camp came back looking twenty years older.

Those who came back at all.

Martha froze.

Grimsby's voice traveled easily through the thin wall.

"Mrs. Higgins."

Abigail answered brightly.

"Mr. Grimsby."

"The payment was due last Monday."

"I know."

"Three hundred dollars."

"I'm aware."

"And yet my pocket remains three hundred dollars lighter than it should."

Martha slowly set down her knife.

Abigail lowered her voice.

Martha moved closer to the doorway.

"I need more time."

"You have had time."

"Winter business will improve."

Grimsby laughed.

"You expect me to believe travelers are coming to Bitter Creek in January?"

Silence.

Then Abigail said, "There must be another arrangement."

Martha heard the chair creak.

Grimsby took his time answering.

"There is."

Something about those words chilled her.

"I own a laundry camp north of here."

"I've heard."

"We service mining settlements. Hard work. Boilers. Scrubbing. Carrying water."

His cane tapped again.

"I need strong workers."

Martha's breathing stopped.

Grimsby continued.

"You cannot pay me money, Mrs. Higgins."

Abigail said nothing.

"But you do have the heavy one."

Martha gripped the doorframe.

Grimsby's voice sharpened with amusement.

"She's built like an ox. Thick arms. Strong back. She could work ten years and probably still be standing."

Martha covered her mouth.

Abigail's reply came almost immediately.

"Martha?"

"Unless you're hiding another one."

A pause.

Then Abigail laughed.

Not nervously.

Not with reluctance.

She laughed as though Grimsby had suggested selling a broken chair.

"You'd erase the full debt?"

"If she signs an indenture."

"She won't."

"Then you sign as household guardian and tell her where she's going after it's done."

Martha felt dizzy.

Abigail asked, "When?"

"End of the month."

The wind pushed against the kitchen window.

Martha heard every word.

Grimsby said, "You should be pleased. One less mouth."

Abigail's answer destroyed whatever small piece of hope Martha still carried.

"Take her at the end of the month. It'll save me a fortune in groceries."

Martha stepped backward.

Her hip struck the worktable.

A tin cup fell.

She caught it just before it hit the floor.

For several seconds she could not breathe.

The end of the month.

Ten days.

They had sold ten years of her life for three hundred dollars.

Perhaps more than ten.

Martha had heard stories about camps near the Dakota border.

Women standing elbow-deep in freezing water until their fingers split.

Steam burns.

Consumption.

Pneumonia.

Men who believed an indebted worker belonged to them in every possible way.

Martha pressed both palms against her chest.

No.

She could not go.

She would run.

But where?

She had twelve cents hidden beneath a loose floorboard upstairs.

Twelve.

Enough for bread.

Not enough for a train ticket.

She had no relatives willing to take her.

No husband.

No close friends.

No property.

No legal power anyone in Bitter Creek would bother respecting if Abigail produced papers and Grimsby produced money.

For the first time in years, Martha abandoned the stove.

She slipped out the rear door.

Cold air struck her face.

She walked behind the woodpile and crouched where no window could see her.

Then she cried.

Quietly.

She had become talented at that too.

She cried for her father.

She cried for all the meals she had cooked but never shared.

She cried because she had spent years making herself useful enough to be allowed to stay, only to discover usefulness was the very reason someone wanted to sell her labor.

Then something changed.

Fear remained.

But underneath it, something harder formed.

Anger.

"No," Martha whispered.

The word disappeared into the wind.

She said it again.

"No."

Nobody had asked Martha what she wanted in years.

Maybe that was why the answer felt unfamiliar.

But she knew it now.

She did not want to die in Horace Grimsby's laundry camp.

She stood.

That evening, after the guests went upstairs, Martha collected newspapers from the parlor to use for kindling.

Most were old.

One had been folded beneath a chair.

The Matrimonial Times.

She nearly threw it into the fire.

Then a line caught her eye.

WANTED: WIFE.

Martha smiled bitterly.

She began reading out of morbid curiosity.

A Nebraska farmer wanted "a cheerful woman under twenty-five."

A Kansas shopkeeper requested "a refined lady of modest proportions."

A rancher in New Mexico preferred "petite, educated, and agreeable."

Martha snorted.

"Of course."

She turned the page.

Near the bottom, squeezed between advertisements for patent medicine and a missing mule, she found something different.

WANTED: A WIFE.

Must withstand severe winters.

Must know how to work.

High in the San Juan Mountains, Colorado.

No time for foolishness.

Send letter to C. O'Rourke, Silverton Post.

Martha read it twice.

Then three times.

No mention of beauty.

No mention of size.

No mention of being delicate.

He wanted someone who could work.

She certainly qualified.

The San Juan Mountains were far away.

Far from Abigail.

Far from Grimsby.

Far from Bitter Creek.

Martha folded the paper.

Her heart pounded.

It was madness.

The man might be cruel.

He might be ancient.

He might smell worse than the boarding-house stable.

He might not answer.

And even if he did, what would happen when he saw her?

Martha closed her eyes.

There was only one way.

She could not deceive him.

If rejection was coming, better for it to arrive in a letter than on a frozen mountain platform.

After midnight, Martha stole a tallow candle stub.

She found butcher paper.

Her only writing tool was a charcoal nub.

She sat at the kitchen table.

For twenty minutes she stared at the blank page.

Finally, she wrote.

Dear Mr. O'Rourke,

I am responding to your advertisement.

I am a strong worker, and severe winters do not frighten me. I know how to cook, clean, mend, preserve food, keep a fire, and make supplies last.

Her fingers stopped.

Now the dangerous part.

She swallowed.

But I must be honest with you.

I am not a beautiful woman.

I am a very large, heavy woman.

I am mocked for my size.

She blinked away tears.

Then wrote the sentence she had heard in different forms her entire life.

In my town, no one marries a fat girl, sir.

Martha stared at the words.

She almost burned the letter.

Instead, she continued.

I understand if you throw this letter into the fire.

But I can cook.

I can make a feast from a barren pantry, and I can keep a hearth warm.

If you will have me, I will be a loyal wife to you.

Sincerely,

Martha Higgins.

She folded the letter carefully.

The following morning, she retrieved five cents from beneath the loose floorboard.

Her last hidden nickel.

At the post office, she placed it on the counter.

"For Silverton, Colorado."

The postmaster stamped the envelope.

Martha watched her entire future disappear into a canvas mailbag.

She had no idea that hundreds of miles away, high in mountains already white with snow, a scarred man named Callum O'Rourke was about to read the one sentence Martha believed would make him reject her.

And instead, it would make him write five words that would change both their lives.

✦
YOUR CHOICE

Cookie preferences

Read and listen either way. You can change your choice at any time using the link in the footer.

Essential & reading preferences

Remember this choice and the bookmarks, text size and listening settings you choose. Also supports security and publisher sign-in.

Always available

Help us understand story visits, chapter progress and listening using a random browser identifier. Advertising is off. This choice does not authorize advertising trackers.

Your choice lasts 180 days on this browser and this website. Read our privacy policy.